Set four years after the series ended, Der Waffle Haus has burned down and head reaper Rube has left due to retirement. The remaining reapers meet their new boss Cameron Kane (Henry Ian Cusick), a “slick business man who couldn’t care less about helping the newly dead.” George (Ellen Muth) reconnects with her sister Reggie (Britt McKillip) when she has to reap the soul of Reggie’s new (and secret) boyfriend, Hudson Hart (Jordan Hudyma). Daisy (now played by Sarah Wynter) is attracted to Cameron, who helps her get a leading role. In a bid to gain the role, Daisy injures the lead actress and due to the stress turns to alcohol, even during the performances.